Voting by mail gains traction, but advocates warn it’s not ‘a panacea’

A voter in Milwaukee this week wore a mask in the Wisconsin primary voting debacle this week that offered a cautionary tale for Georgia and other states grappling with how to vote during a pandemic. Scott Olson/Getty Images

WASHINGTON — As the COVID-19 virus continues to sweep the country, voting rights advocates are demanding Congress fully fund a national vote-by-mail program so people aren’t forced to choose between their health and their right to vote. 

But for large swaths of the population, voting by mail isn’t a viable option. 

The voting debacle in Wisconsin last week offered a cautionary tale for other states grappling with how to vote during a pandemic. 

When Wisconsin’s Supreme Court ruled their April 7 election could not be postponed, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to give absentee voters more time, people were forced to risk their health in order to vote. In hard hit, predominantly black areas, like Milwaukee, a shortage of poll workers led to further crowding at fewer polls, disproportionately impacting populations that are already more vulnerable to the virus, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Lawmakers and advocates took to Twitter to demand vote-by-mail. “This is an outrage. Americans need #VoteByMail,” wrote Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden (D). 

California Rep. Adam Schiff (D) wrote: “We need to be prepared for easy and secure vote by mail everywhere in November. It’s non negotiable.” 

But remote voting doesn’t work for many with disabilities, those who require assistance reading, those without a permanent address, Native populations without reliable mail delivery, many with limited English, and still others who have a historic distrust of the system. 

Allison Riggs, chief voting counsel for Southern Coalition for Social Justice, said that during the Jim Crow era, it was not uncommon for black voters’ registration and ballots to be stolen.  

“That was the white supremacy machine getting rid of black votes,” she said. “That’s a lasting scar and trauma that is part of the reason historically in the South, black voters have tended to prefer in person voting.” 

Sam Berger, the vice president of democracy and government reform for the Center for American Progress, said there are a number of common steps officials across the country can take to ensure elections are safe and yield stable voter turnout.  

“It’s not that they’re easy. They’re complicated and take time and resources. But we know what they are,” he said. “Vote by mail, and at the same time, maintain in-person options and expand them.”  

Congress allotted $400 million for voting administration in its last COVID-19 relief bill, billions short of what advocates say is needed. In a preliminary calculation, the Brennan Center estimated it would cost $2 billion to ensure safe, enfranchised voting. 

Another problem, Berger said, is that the pandemic is playing into broader voting-related politics. 

At a recent press conference, President Donald Trump called voting by mail “horrible” and “corrupt.” When a reporter pointed out that Trump had voted by mail in the last election, the president said, it was “because I’m allowed to.”

Trump later clarified in a Tweet that voting by mail is fine for members of the military and senior citizens, but is “ripe for fraud” for others. 

‘It’s shameful’ 

Georgia House Speaker David Ralston, a Blue Ridge Republican, has said heavy reliance on voting by mail in the primary “will be extremely devastating to Republicans and conservatives.” He later explained that he meant to say widespread absentee voting could lead to election fraud. 

While Georgia’s Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger decided to send Georgia’s 6.9 million active voters an absentee ballot application, he has not provided postage, angering advocates. He has also said he will establish a task force to prevent voter fraud.  

Georgia U.S. Rep. Hank Johnson. Win McNamee/Getty Images

Georgia Democratic Congressman Hank Johnson called Raffensperger’s task force a “PR pitch to put himself into the good graces of Donald Trump.” 

He told the Georgia Recorder in an interview, “I question the motives and sincerity of the Secretary of State for creating that task force and wasting precious resources that could be put toward encouraging people to vote by mail and remain safe. It’s a waste of taxpayer money. It’s shameful.” 

Shame on those pseudo patriots who are doing everything they can to stop people from exercising their fundamental right to vote,” Johnson added. 

Raffensperger also postponed the May primaries until June 9, but Democratic critics say the move is not enough.

“Delaying Georgia’s election does not ensure either public safety or Georgians’ right to vote without the Secretary of State taking further action to make vote by mail truly accessible for all Georgians — that means providing paid postage, counting all ballots postmarked by Election Day, and mailing vote-by-mail ballots to all registered voters, not just some,” Democratic Party of Georgia voter protection director Saira Draper said in a statement. 

State Sen. Nikema Williams, an Atlanta Democrat, is one of six Georgia lawmakers who contracted COVID-19. She told a group of reporters on a Friday conference call that it took her three weeks to recover from the disease.

“I don’t wish this on any Georgian,” said Williams, who said she emailed back her absentee ballot application because she doesn’t keep stamps on hand at home.

“We need to do everything that we can to encourage Georgians to stay home,” Williams said. “And so it is difficult for me to encourage people to show up in person to vote, knowing the health concerns that are out there and knowing that we’re still facing a global pandemic. We need to make sure that vote by mail is accessible for everyone.”

While states work to expand voting options during the pandemic, many advocates are urging officials to keep in mind people who cannot vote by mail. 

“As we are looking at options, we need to include options that work for the disability community, people with language access issues, native populations, and others who might not have a permanent address,” said Sylvia Albert, director of voting and elections for Common Cause. 

“Those people who cannot be forgotten in our rush to find a perfect fix.”

Kat Calvin is the founder of Spread of the Vote, a group that works to help the large population of American citizens without proof of identification, about 11 percent of eligible voters, obtain government-issued IDs in order to exercise their right to vote. She said many of the people she works with are unhoused and do not have access to the internet. 

So what happens if it is all vote by mail? How do we help our clients?” she said. “If we have to do virtual education, can we ship a laptop to one of our shelter partners? But we can’t have a bunch of people crowded in a room around a computer. Can I put on a hazmat suit and pick up some ballots for them?” 

Calvin said vote-by-mail should be part of a comprehensive voting package, but it’s not “a panacea.” 

Terry Ao Minnis, senior director of census and voting programs for Asian Americans Advancing Justice, said language barriers are a main driver for a consistent turnout gap between Asian American voters and white voters, and the confusion caused by the pandemic — in combination with xenophobic harassment and discrimination against Asians and Asian Americans — is only making matters worse. 

“It is possible this harmful sentiment spills over into the voting context where we have already seen discrimination against Asian Americans because of false perceptions of the ‘perpetual foreigner,’” she said. “We may see an increase in unfounded challenges to Asian American voters for simply being Asian or we could even see an increase in attacks against Asian Americans seeking to vote.” 

Voting rights advocates agree that while conducting primaries during the pandemic is complicated, politically fraught, and logistically frustrating, it is necessary to ensure the funds are secured and the kinks are worked out before the general election in November. 

Everyone kind of needs to pony up right now,” Riggs said. “If our democracy dies during this pandemic in addition to thousands of Americans, it’s really game over.”

Georgia Recorder Deputy Editor Jill Nolin contributed to this report.